Should I break up with him?
I've been going out with my first serious boyfriend (I'm a late starter at 25). He was the first guy I've given my all to. We' been going out about 7 months. He has depression, and can be self absorbed and aloof from time to time. I myself am an insecure person, but I try to reason with myself internally and not let it affect my relationship too much.
My boyfriend did not allow me to visit his house. It bothered me a lot. He came up here to my house and I went to his family's house but not his own. I've met his family and friends so I didn't think he could have been hiding anything too bad. He said he was ashamed of his place and needed time to sort the mess out. He has a female housemate who is apparently aware he has a girlfriend. When I asked him about her, he said they met through work, weren't particularly close but she needed a place to stay and he needed a tenant.
Last night, the topic of me coming to his house arose. He set a date for me to visit and I was delighted that it was finally happening. I told him not to worry and I wouldn't be judging him for a messy house. His housemate came into the conversation and he told me that she had a small share in the mortgage. I was shocked because he hadn't told me this before. I said; "Well you must have been close to pay for a house together" and he agreed as if this had been an obvious open fact all along. I asked how they had met, he said they met over a decade ago through the internet and that she had had a hard time and he helped her out as a friend. I was shocked because he had told me they met through work and it was simply a work colleague he was politely friendly with.
I told him that he had lied to me and he insisted that I had been mistaken, or he had gotten mixed up/misheard me etc. He would not admit to the lie. I gave him the chance to admit to it but he wouldn't. I said if he had of just been honest about this it wouldn't have been as big of an issue as it is now but now I don't know what else he could be lying about. According to him, they never had a sexual relationship, just a friendship.
He left my place and sent a couple of txts saying he was bewildered as to why some confusion would ruin our relationship, not acknowledging the lies he told. I ignored them, seeing no point in replying. I am heartbroken. I am alone in a new country and trying to cope with this situation. Friends and family I have phoned, tell me it's my decision what to do, but I don't trust my own judgement. My mind says no this won't work out but my heart says try to sort things out with him. I'm not sure I could ever trust someone capable of lying like that. Please give me some solid advise on the situation. I need to feel I did the right thing.


Comments
When you say you are alone in a new country, would I be right in assuming you moved to another country for this guy? It also sounds as if you family are letting you make your own decision and for some reason you are unable to trust your own judgment. Would this be because this is your first serious relationship and you re not quite sure how you feel/should feel about things are the moment.
You really are applying the right processes for working this situation out for yourself - sometimes our mind knows better than our heart what is right. Trust takes time to build up in any relationship and you had only been together for seven months. Take a look at the relationship insights on this site, particularly the article on the stages of a relationship which may help to improve your understanding of how things evolve.
The rest of the community may have a different view but it sounds like you are experiencing a very human feeling of have I done the right thing!
Thanks for taking the time to read and reply. No I moved here by myself for an experience and met him soon after. I suppose I don't have a lot of confidence or experience when it comes to relationships so I don't trust my judgement completely. My instinct says I probably did the right thing. I don't think I deserve to be treated this way. I was in trouble for simply expecting honesty and questioning his dishonesty. Like I said, I told him I just wanted to know why he didn't tell the truth. He refused to admit he had lied and became angry at me. Anyways, I asked him again yesterday and eventually he admitted he lied to me because his situation "sounded dodgy" and because of my "jealousy". I don't think I'm a hugely jealous individual, no more than the next woman. I could have even accepted that he lived and shared a mortgage with a female friend of his, as weird as that sounds. But he couldn't be honest about having told lies. I feel like I probably made the right decision.I don't believe he lied for my sake. I believe he lied because he was cowardly. And who's to say what he could lie about in the future. He wasn't trustworthy. I will miss him so much but I won't sacrifice my own self respect out of a fear of being without him.
Stay strong - as you're worried he's been lying to you then the trust isn't there, and without trust a relationship struggles.
You really sound like a strong woman. Good for you
Thanks very much for your comments guys. Life is too short and precious to settle for someone not good enough.